How to read a Fed statement
The Federal Open Market Committee meets eight times a year. After each meeting it releases a statement of a few hundred words, and markets often move more on that statement than on a typical quarterly earnings report. The document is short and formulaic, and it is written to be read side by side with the previous one. Most of what it says only means something relative to what the committee said last time.
Below is what the statement contains, in the order it appears, and what each part tells you.
The opening paragraph describes the economy
The statement starts with the committee's assessment of growth, the labor market and inflation. The underlying data is already public by then, so this section rarely contains new facts. What it contains is the committee's choice of words, and the words change deliberately.
Suppose one statement says job gains "have been robust" and the next says they "have moderated." Everyone saw the same payroll reports in between. The change tells you how the committee now reads those reports, and that reading usually shows up in the next decision. Economists compare statements word by word for this reason, and several news outlets publish a marked-up version showing every change.
The rate decision is usually expected
The second part announces the target range for the federal funds rate. Before the announcement, interest rate futures typically price the outcome at better than 90% probability. Surprises do happen, most often when the committee believes markets have misread the data, but they are uncommon.
This is the part most headlines lead with, and it tends to move prices the least. A decision that traders expected is already reflected in bond yields, currency rates and stock valuations by the time it is announced.
The guidance paragraph moves markets
Next the committee describes how it expects to proceed and what it will watch. This is guidance in the central-banking sense, and it is where most of the market reaction comes from.
The path of rates matters more than any single move. If rates stay at the current level for two more meetings, that implies one set of borrowing costs and discount rates. If they stay for eight, the math changes for every loan, bond and valuation model that depends on them. A statement can leave the rate unchanged and still reprice markets if it suggests the next move is more likely to be a cut than a hike.
Pay attention to how firm the wording is. "The committee expects" commits to less than "the committee anticipates it will be appropriate." Dropping a phrase can be a signal in its own right. In 2014 the committee removed its pledge to keep rates low for a "considerable time," and markets treated the removal as news. Because of that, the committee retires phrases slowly and usually prepares markets in advance.
The vote shows how united the committee is
The statement ends by listing who voted for the decision and who dissented. Most decisions are unanimous. When members dissent, it shows how wide the range of opinion is inside the committee. A chair managing a divided committee has less room to change course quickly.
Two or three dissents on one decision is unusual in recent decades, and it suggests the next decision will be harder to predict.
Three related documents
People often mix up the statement with three other releases.
The Summary of Economic Projections comes out at every other meeting, four times a year. It includes the dot plot, where each participant marks where they expect the rate to be at the end of the next several years. The dots are anonymous and non-binding, and they have often turned out wrong. They are still the clearest published view of where committee members think rates are going.
The press conference follows the statement. The statement itself is negotiated among members and written to say as little as possible. The chair answering questions in real time is where more detail comes out, and occasionally a remark that moves markets.
The minutes are published three weeks later. They summarize the discussion in detail without naming who said what. The decision is old news by then, but the minutes show how close the vote was and what arguments might change the outcome next time. Many investors skip them, which is one reason they are worth reading.
A ten-minute routine
- Open the previous statement next to the new one. The Federal Reserve publishes both, and several outlets publish a comparison with changes highlighted. Read the changes first.
- Check the rate decision against expectations. If it matched, move on quickly, since markets had already priced it in.
- Read the guidance paragraph twice. Look first at what it says, then at any phrase from the last statement that is now missing.
- Check the vote for dissents.
- At projection meetings, look at the median dot for the end of next year. The current-year dots usually sit close to what markets already expect. The later years show where members disagree.
Why this vocabulary matters
Much of the language of finance developed to describe these situations. Hawkish and dovish (hawkish, dovish) describe the two directions of concern. Tightening and easing describe the two directions of policy. Taper means slowing an asset purchase program without reversing it. Each word stands in for a sentence or two of explanation, which is why financial writers use them constantly, and why a reader who doesn't know them can lose track of an otherwise simple article.
Guess Macro is built around the same idea. Each clue describes a situation, and the answer is the word a practitioner would use for it. The more of these words you recognize, the easier it gets to follow what a Fed statement, or a news story about one, is saying.
Common questions
How do you tell what actually changed in a Fed statement?
Read it beside the previous statement rather than on its own. The document is deliberately formulaic, so most of its meaning is relative. When job gains move from "robust" to "moderated", everyone saw the same payroll data in between; the changed wording is the new information.
Which part of an FOMC statement moves markets?
Usually the guidance paragraph rather than the rate decision. The decision itself is normally expected and already priced in. What markets have not seen is how the committee frames what comes next, and the vote shows how united it is behind that view.
How often does the FOMC meet?
Eight times a year. Each meeting ends with a statement of a few hundred words, which can move markets more than a typical quarterly earnings report.
Guess Macro is a daily word game built on this vocabulary. Five clues, one word each.